11/18/2004|||110078245351439252||||||

CARICATURES OR RACISM?

Some big-name cartoonists are coming under fire for their depictions of Condoleezza Rice. I'm not sure all the evidence is quite as clear-cut as some commentators seem to think. There's no question, though, about the offensiveness of the Danziger "Mammy" drawing. Garry Trudeau is on thin ice too.

MEANWHILE.....

Peggy Noonan offers typically thoughtful points about Condi-as-symbol:

"It is considered corny to point this out. But corny's not all bad. Look at it this way. In every U.S. embassy and consulate in the world very soon, non-Americans will walk in to see two things: a picture of the American president and next to it a picture of the young black woman who is this nation's secretary of state. They will notice this, and consciously or not they will think: This truly must be some kind of country.

"Is there a drawback to her appointment? There must be. There is a drawback to everything. The Bush cabinet is getting very Bushian. That sends a clear message. But you don't always want to send a clear message. Sometimes you want to confuse things. Sometimes you want to give an unclear message to the world so that it will sit down and scratch its head, in silence. When Colin Powell was secretary of state, foreign leaders didn't know exactly where he stood, either in terms of policy or internally, in his place in the Bush hierarchy. It confused them. This was so wonderful. They confided all sorts of things to him because they didn't know what he'd respond to or how or what he'd bring home and wouldn't. It's good when foreign leaders confide. It can be good when they don't know...

"The criticism of Ms. Rice has been fascinating. Her critics need to sit down and have a Coke, as Bob Dole said. A friend said to me yesterday, "She is boring." I thought, really? You can't be boring enough; we've had quite enough excitement.

"Another person said, "She's not very feminine." My first thought was: Neither was Colin.
My second thought was: How startling is this conversation? I should probably explain it was held in Manhattan.

"I think she is extremely ladylike in her bearing and manner," I said. "Soft voice, pastel suits, heels, not a hair out of place."

"Yes," my friend said, "but she doesn't give off any sparks of sexuality."

"That's another thing I like about her", I said. We don't want a secretary of state running around giving off sparks of sexuality, do we. We don't want a secretary of state giving off sparks at all. We want a nice, quiet, calming, competent, sophisticated, even-keeled person to do a good, solid, nonshowy job."

|||Clive|||http://clivedavis.blogspot.com/2004/11/caricatures-or-racism-some-big-name.html|||11/18/2004 01:43:00 pm|||||||||

|||